| 3 | EM Mann | Merion v Germantown | Merion Cricket Club Ground, Haverford | hc821 |
| 3 | JH Briggs | Merion v New York and Metropolitan District Cricket League | Silver Lake, Staten Island | hc823 |
| 3 | JH Briggs | Philadelphia Cricket Club v New York and Metropolitan District Cricket League | St Martin's, Philadelphia | hc834 |
| 3 | HW Middleton | Merion v Philadelphia Cricket Club | Merion Cricket Club Ground, Haverford | hc835 |
| 2 | CC Morris | Germantown v Merion | Merion Cricket Club Ground, Haverford | hc821 |
| 2 | G Bennett | Philadelphia Cricket Club v Frankford | St Martin's, Philadelphia | hc822 |
| 2 | JW Muir | Frankford v Philadelphia Cricket Club | St Martin's, Philadelphia | hc822 |
| 2 | G Bennett | Philadelphia Cricket Club v Frankford | St Martin's, Philadelphia | hc822 |
| 2 | FC Taylor | Philadelphia Cricket Club v New York and Metropolitan District Cricket League | Livingston Field, Staten Island | hc825 |
| 2 | GF Bottomley | Germantown v Frankford | Germantown Cricket Club Ground, Manheim, Philadelphia | hc824 |
| 2 | WP O'Neill | Frankford v Germantown | Germantown Cricket Club Ground, Manheim, Philadelphia | hc824 |
| 2 | PN LeRoy | Merion v Philadelphia Cricket Club | St Martin's, Philadelphia | hc827 |
| 2 | HS Harned | New York and Metropolitan District Cricket League v Germantown | West New Brighton, Staten Island | hc826 |
| 2 | FS Franklin | Frankford v New York and Metropolitan District Cricket League | Merion Cricket Club Ground, Haverford | hc828 |
| 2 | HBH Boyce | Merion v New York and Metropolitan District Cricket League | Merion Cricket Club Ground, Haverford | hc829 |
| 2 | SH Hart | Merion v Frankford | Merion Cricket Club Ground, Haverford | hc831 |
| 2 | JS Dixon | Merion v Frankford | Merion Cricket Club Ground, Haverford | hc831 |
| 2 | JH Mason | Germantown v Philadelphia Cricket Club | Germantown Cricket Club Ground, Manheim, Philadelphia | hc830 |
| 2 | EM Mann | Philadelphia Cricket Club v Germantown | Germantown Cricket Club Ground, Manheim, Philadelphia | hc830 |
| 2 | M Duncan | Germantown v Philadelphia Cricket Club | Germantown Cricket Club Ground, Manheim, Philadelphia | hc830 |
| 2 | RP Anderson | Philadelphia Cricket Club v Germantown | Germantown Cricket Club Ground, Manheim, Philadelphia | hc830 |
| 2 | EM Mann | Philadelphia Cricket Club v Germantown | Germantown Cricket Club Ground, Manheim, Philadelphia | hc830 |
| 2 | A Lee | Germantown v Merion | Germantown Cricket Club Ground, Manheim, Philadelphia | hc833 |
| 2 | R Lee | Philadelphia Cricket Club v Merion | Merion Cricket Club Ground, Haverford | hc835 |
| 2 | SH Hart | Merion v Frankford | Merion Cricket Club Ground, Haverford | hc837 |
| 2 | GF Bottomley | Merion v Frankford | Merion Cricket Club Ground, Haverford | hc837 |
| 2 | FA Greene | Philadelphia Cricket Club v Germantown | St Martin's, Philadelphia | hc838 |
| 2 | RP Anderson | New York and Metropolitan District Cricket League v Germantown | Germantown Cricket Club Ground, Manheim, Philadelphia | hc839 |
