| 4 | ED Weekes | India v West Indies | 1952/53 | f19934 |
| 4 | LG Rowe | Guyana v Jamaica | 1981/82 | f34000 |
| 4 | MD Crowe | West Indies v New Zealand | 1984/85 | f35733 |
| 4 | JC Adams | Windward Islands v Jamaica | 1988/89 | f37965 |
| 4 | IVA Richards | India v West Indies | 1988/89 | f38058 |
| 4 | JC Adams | England v West Indies | 1993/94 | f40989 |
| 4 | BC Lara | Australia v West Indies | 1994/95 | f41724 |
| 4 | BC Lara | India v West Indies | 2006 | f49434 |
| 4 | DP Hyatt | Barbados v Jamaica | 2011/12 | f54000 |
| 4 | DE Johnson | Jamaica v Windward Islands | 2016/17 | f57490 |
| 4 | D Ramdin | Jamaica v Trinidad and Tobago | 2017/18 | f58343 |
| 4 | J Blackwood | Leeward Islands v Jamaica | 2017/18 | f58438 |
| 3 | EG Hull | RA Bennett's XI v Jamaica | 1901/02 | f5752 |
| 3 | EC Lee | Jamaica v RA Bennett's XI | 1901/02 | f5752 |
| 3 | LS Constantine | Jamaica v Trinidad | 1905 | f6721 |
| 3 | CS Morrison | Marylebone Cricket Club v Jamaica | 1910/11 | f8193 |
| 3 | LN Constantine | Sir J Cahn's XI v West Indies XI | 1928/29 | f12607 |
| 3 | LN Constantine | Sir J Cahn's XI v West Indies XI | 1928/29 | f12607 |
| 3 | OC Da Costa | England v West Indies | 1929/30 | f13021 |
| 3 | JDC Goddard | Jamaica v Barbados | 1946/47 | f17451 |
| 3 | L Hutton | West Indies v England | 1947/48 | f17850 |
| 3 | RJ Christiani | Jamaica v British Guiana | 1950/51 | f19059 |
| 3 | JKC Holt | British Guiana v Jamaica | 1950/51 | f19059 |
| 3 | PR Umrigar | Jamaica v Indians | 1952/53 | f19932 |
| 3 | AF Rae | Indians v Jamaica | 1952/53 | f19932 |
| 3 | RB Kanhai | Jamaica v British Guiana | 1965/66 | f26166 |
| 3 | MC Cowdrey | Jamaica v Marylebone Cricket Club | 1967/68 | f27129 |
| 3 | LG Rowe | International Cavaliers v Jamaica | 1969/70 | f28103 |
| 3 | AG Barrett | Guyana v Jamaica | 1969/70 | f28114 |
| 3 | EDAS McMorris | Indians v Jamaica | 1970/71 | f28568 |
| 3 | DAJ Holford | Jamaica v Barbados | 1970/71 | f28636 |
| 3 | LG Rowe | Combined Leeward and Windward Islands v Jamaica | 1971/72 | f29010 |
| 3 | GM Turner | Jamaica v New Zealanders | 1971/72 | f29036 |
| 3 | RS Gabriel | Jamaica v Trinidad and Tobago | 1972/73 | f29500 |
| 3 | LG Rowe | Combined Leeward and Windward Islands v Jamaica | 1973/74 | f29960 |
| 3 | RC Fredericks | England v West Indies | 1973/74 | f30010 |
| 3 | PM Toohey | Jamaica v Australians | 1977/78 | f32015 |
| 3 | RA Harper | Jamaica v Guyana | 1981/82 | f34000 |
| 3 | CH Lloyd | Jamaica v Guyana | 1981/82 | f34000 |
| 3 | G Powell | Guyana v Jamaica | 1981/82 | f34000 |
| 3 | J Garner | India v West Indies | 1982/83 | f34526 |
| 3 | MA Holding | Guyana v Jamaica | 1985/86 | f36133 |
| 3 | AN Hayhurst | Jamaica v Lancashire | 1987/88 | f37480 |
| 3 | DS Morgan | Guyana v Jamaica | 1988/89 | f37936 |
| 3 | AL Kelly | Jamaica v Leeward Islands | 1988/89 | f37952 |
| 3 | MA Holding | Leeward Islands v Jamaica | 1988/89 | f37952 |
| 3 | OW Peters | Barbados v Jamaica | 1989/90 | f38500 |
| 3 | KLT Arthurton | Jamaica v Leeward Islands | 1989/90 | f38582 |
| 3 | SM Skeete | Jamaica v Barbados | 1990/91 | f39208 |
| 3 | CL Hooper | Australia v West Indies | 1990/91 | f39242 |
| 3 | RC Haynes | Leeward Islands v Jamaica | 1991/92 | f39797 |
| 3 | RA Harper | Jamaica v Guyana | 1993/94 | f40882 |
| 3 | DS Morgan | Guyana v Jamaica | 1993/94 | f40882 |
| 3 | DA Joseph | Jamaica v Windward Islands | 1993/94 | f40950 |
| 3 | EJ Warrican | Jamaica v Windward Islands | 1993/94 | f40950 |
| 3 | JC Adams | Australia v West Indies | 1994/95 | f41724 |
| 3 | NC McGarrell | Jamaica v Guyana | 1995/96 | f42248 |
| 3 | TO Powell | Windward Islands v Jamaica | 1995/96 | f42309 |
| 3 | U Pope | Jamaica v Windward Islands | 1995/96 | f42309 |
| 3 | TO Powell | Guyana v Jamaica | 1998/99 | f44124 |
| 3 | DRE Joseph | Australia v West Indies | 1998/99 | f44333 |
| 3 | FA Rose | Barbados v Jamaica | 1999/00 | f44920 |
| 3 | FL Reifer | Jamaica v Barbados | 1999/00 | f44920 |
| 3 | SC Joseph | Jamaica v Leeward Islands | 1999/00 | f45018 |
| 3 | JAR Sylvester | Jamaica v Windward Islands | 2000/01 | f45518 |
| 3 | VS Solanki | Jamaica v England A | 2000/01 | f45611 |
| 3 | MO Kepple | Windward Islands v Jamaica | 2002/03 | f47135 |
| 3 | CH Gayle | Sri Lanka v West Indies | 2003 | f47330 |
| 3 | BC Lara | Sri Lanka v West Indies | 2003 | f47330 |
| 3 | OAC Banks | Bangladesh v West Indies | 2004 | f48008 |
| 3 | DR Smith | Bangladesh v West Indies | 2004 | f48008 |
| 3 | DE Bernard | Leeward Islands v Jamaica | 2007/08 | f50551 |
| 3 | MN Samuels | Trinidad and Tobago v Jamaica | 2007/08 | f50797 |
| 3 | D Bishoo | India v West Indies | 2011 | f53268 |
| 3 | RO Hinds | Jamaica v Barbados | 2011/12 | f53827 |
| 3 | NA Bolan | Jamaica v Leeward Islands | 2011/12 | f53844 |
| 3 | LR Johnson | Jamaica v Guyana | 2011/12 | f53968 |
| 3 | SC Joseph | Jamaica v Leeward Islands | 2012/13 | f54757 |
| 3 | H Miller | Guyana v Jamaica | 2013/14 | f55474 |
| 3 | JD Campbell | Guyana v Jamaica | 2013/14 | f55474 |
| 3 | JD Campbell | Windward Islands v Jamaica | 2013/14 | f55535 |
| 3 | NO Miller | Leeward Islands v Jamaica | 2015/16 | f56807 |
| 3 | SSW Liburd | Jamaica v Leeward Islands | 2015/16 | f56807 |
| 3 | KA Joseph | Jamaica v Guyana | 2015/16 | f56836 |
| 3 | AM McCarthy | Trinidad and Tobago v Jamaica | 2015/16 | f56972 |
| 3 | KL Rahul | West Indies v India | 2016 | f57190 |
| 3 | TA Griffith | Windward Islands v Jamaica | 2016/17 | f57490 |
| 3 | SSJ Brooks | Jamaica v Barbados | 2016/17 | f57518 |
| 3 | JD Campbell | Trinidad and Tobago v Jamaica | 2016/17 | f57580 |
| 3 | LR Johnson | Jamaica v Guyana | 2016/17 | f57800 |
| 3 | JL Carter | Jamaica v Barbados | 2018/19 | f59373 |
| 3 | KAR Hodge | Jamaica v Windward Islands | 2019/20 | f59885 |
| 3 | Imran Butt | West Indies v Pakistan | 2021 | f60478 |
| 3 | C Brown | Leeward Islands v Jamaica | 2023/24 | f62191 |
| 3 | KAR Hodge | Bangladesh v West Indies | 2024/25 | f62621 |
