| 5 | JT Murray | for Middlesex | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | 1968 | a117 |
| 5 | JT Murray | for Middlesex | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1975 | a1443 |
| 5 | WK Hegg | for Lancashire | Old Trafford, Manchester | 1990 | a6486 |
| 5 | KM Krikken | for Derbyshire | The Foster's Oval, Kennington | 1998 | a11322 |
| 4 | BJ Meyer | for Gloucestershire | Woodbridge Road, Guildford | 1970 | a323 |
| 4 | APE Knott | for Kent | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1973 | a930 |
| 4 | RW Tolchard | for Leicestershire | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | 1974 | a1238 |
| 4 | EW Jones | for Glamorgan | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1974 | a1264 |
| 4 | G Sharp | for Northamptonshire | Wardown Park, Luton | 1974 | a1275 |
| 4 | N Smith | for Essex | Southchurch Park, Southend-on-Sea | 1978 | a2281 |
| 4 | APE Knott | for Kent | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1980 | a2794 |
| 4 | G Sharp | for Northamptonshire | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1981 | a2991 |
| 4 | APE Knott | for Kent | St Lawrence Ground, Canterbury | 1983 | a3638 |
| 4 | RJ Parks | for Hampshire | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1984 | a4034 |
| 4 | GW Humpage | for Warwickshire | Edgbaston, Birmingham | 1984 | a4158 |
| 4 | DE East | for Essex | County Ground, Chelmsford | 1988 | a5608 |
| 4 | RC Russell | for Gloucestershire | The Foster's Oval, Kennington | 1991 | a7030 |
| 4 | CP Metson | for Glamorgan | St Helen's, Swansea | 1992 | a7614 |
| 4 | ND Burns | for Somerset | County Ground, Taunton | 1993 | a8156 |
| 4 | SJ Rhodes | for Worcestershire | County Ground, New Road, Worcester | 1995 | a9268 |
| 4 | AC Gilchrist | for Young Australia | The Foster's Oval, Kennington | 1995 | a9370 |
| 4 | CMW Read | for Nottinghamshire | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1999 | a11889 |
| 4 | AN Aymes | for Hampshire | County Ground, Southampton | 2000 | a12813 |
| 4 | KJ Piper | for Warwickshire | Edgbaston, Birmingham | 2001 | a13625 |
| 4 | DC Nash | for Middlesex | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | 2002 | a14244 |
| 4 | SJ Rhodes | for Worcestershire | County Ground, New Road, Worcester | 2003 | a15086 |
| 4 | JS Foster | for Essex | The Brit Oval, Kennington | 2004 | a15903 |
| 4 | C Kieswetter | for Somerset | Recreation Ground, Bath | 2007 | a18266 |
| 4 | MA Wallace | for Glamorgan | The SWALEC Stadium, Cardiff | 2008 | a19078 |
| 4 | SM Guy | for Yorkshire | Headingley, Leeds | 2009 | a19783 |
| 4 | P Mustard | for Durham | Emirates Durham International Cricket Ground, Chester-le-Street | 2012 | a22082 |
| 4 | P Mustard | for Durham | Emirates Durham International Cricket Ground, Chester-le-Street | 2015 | a24178 |
| 4 | AWR Barrow | for Somerset | County Ground, Taunton | 2015 | a24224 |
| 4 | AJA Wheater | for Essex | The Kia Oval, Kennington | 2017 | a25516 |
| 4 | T Banton | for Somerset | The Cooper Associates County Ground, Taunton | 2019 | a27373 |
| 4 | GID Lavelle | for Lancashire | Woodbridge Road, Guildford | 2023 | a30152 |
