| 1923 | | W Walker |
| 1925 | | H Larwood, B Lilley |
| 1926 | | A Staples |
| 1927 | | W Voce |
| 1931 | | GV Gunn, J Hardstaff, CB Harris, WW Keeton, AB Wheat |
| 1932 | | FW Shipston |
| 1935 | | GFH Heane |
| 1936 | | J Knowles |
| 1937 | | HJ Butler, FG Woodhead |
| 1939 | | A Jepson, EA Meads |
| 1946 | | TB Reddick, RT Simpson, FW Stocks |
| 1947 | | WA Sime, FH Winrow |
| 1949 | | PF Harvey, CJ Poole |
| 1951 | | RJ Giles |
| 1952 | | JD Clay |
| 1953 | | B Dooland |
| 1954 | | EJ Martin, EJ Rowe |
| 1955 | | G Goonesena, K Smales |
| 1956 | | AK Walker |
| 1957 | | G Millman |
| 1959 | | NW Hill |
| 1960 | | J Cotton, JD Springall, BD Wells |
| 1961 | | M Hill |
| 1962 | | AJ Corran, IJ Davison, HM Winfield |
| 1963 | | JB Bolus |
| 1965 | | C Forbes, HI Moore |
| 1966 | | MJ Smedley, R Swetman, RA White |
| 1967 | | DL Murray, MNS Taylor |
| 1968 | | DJ Halfyard, GS Sobers |
| 1969 | | B Stead |
| 1970 | | MJ Harris, SB Hassan |
| 1971 | | DA Pullan |
| 1973 | | DW Randall |
| 1974 | | JD Bond, PA Wilkinson |
| 1975 | | PD Johnson, AH Latchman, CEB Rice, W Taylor |
| 1977 | | DR Doshi, PA Todd |
| 1978 | | RJ Hadlee |
| 1980 | | MK Bore, KE Cooper, BN French, PJ Hacker, EE Hemmings |
| 1981 | | JD Birch |
| 1982 | | M Hendrick |
| 1983 | | RT Robinson |
| 1984 | | BC Broad, K Saxelby |
| 1986 | | P Johnson |
| 1987 | | M Newell, RA Pick |
| 1988 | | CW Scott, FD Stephenson |
| 1990 | | JA Afford, KP Evans |
| 1992 | | PR Pollard |
| 1993 | | CL Cairns |
| 1994 | | CC Lewis |
| 1995 | | GF Archer, WM Noon |
| 1997 | | MN Bowen, CM Tolley |
| 1998 | | MP Dowman, JER Gallian |
| 1999 | | VC Drakes, PJ Franks, CMW Read |
| 2000 | | U Afzaal, DJ Bicknell, AJ Harris, DJ Millns, JE Morris, PR Reiffel, RD Stemp |
| 2001 | | GS Blewett, GJ Smith |
| 2002 | | SCG MacGill, KP Pietersen |
| 2004 | | MA Ealham, DJ Hussey, RJ Sidebottom, RJ Warren |
| 2005 | | SP Fleming |
| 2006 | | CE Shreck |
| 2007 | | AR Adams, MA Wagh |
| 2008 | | SCJ Broad, SR Patel, DJ Pattinson, AG Prince, AC Voges |
| 2009 | | AD Brown |
| 2010 | | HM Amla |
| 2011 | | DM Bravo, AD Hales |
| 2012 | | MJ Lumb, JWA Taylor |
| 2013 | | EJM Cowan, SJ Mullaney |
| 2014 | | LJ Fletcher, JEC Franklin, HF Gurney, PA Jaques, PM Siddle, MH Wessels |
| 2015 | | BW Hilfenhaus, Imran Tahir, VD Philander, BRM Taylor |
| 2016 | | JT Ball, JM Bird, DT Christian |
| 2017 | | JL Pattinson, CA Pujara |
| 2018 | | KC Brathwaite, BM Duckett, LRPL Taylor |
| 2019 | | R Ashwin |
| 2020 | | H Hameed |
| 2021 | | JM Clarke, BA Hutton, TJ Moores, D Paterson, BT Slater |
| 2023 | | AM Fernando, OP Stone, WA Young |
| 2024 | | LW James, K Verreynne |
| 2025 | | JA Haynes, LA Patterson-White, DY Pennington |